Tuesday, 21 February 2017

Good News! We only have to wait 1 million years for the environment to get better!

quote [ Life appears to have recovered faster than we thought after the worst mass extinction event in our planet's history, nicknamed the Great Dying. New evidence suggests that once the Permian-Triassic extinction hit Earth 252 million years ago, life rebounded in 1 million years - a far cry from the 10 to 20 million years that previous research has indicated. ]

Make Anthropocene Great Again!

More from the NY Times: "After Earth’s Worst Mass Extinction, Life Rebounded Rapidly, Fossils Suggest".

Original paper from Science Advances: "Unexpected Early Triassic marine ecosystem and the rise of the Modern evolutionary fauna".

Relevance to current environment: The Holocene Extinction.

Thumb critter is from the Paris Biota.

SPOILER: 1 Million Years Hence
Reveal

HUNTER SYMBIONT
Moderator baiuli

Communication between hunter and carrier has been simplified to a telepathic link – the huge slow-moving tundra-dwellers controlled directly by the weaker but agile-minded hunters. Fights, when they happen, are usually ritual. Death is unexpected.

(From Man After Man.)
[SFW] [environment & nature] [+1 Interesting]
[by Ankylosaur@9:39pmGMT]

Comments

arrowhen said @ 10:08pm GMT on 21st Feb [Score:4 Funsightful]
Light the celebratory tire fires!
knumbknutz said @ 4:38am GMT on 22nd Feb
While simultaneously clubbing a baby seal!
lilmookieesquire said @ 10:17pm GMT on 21st Feb [Score:1 Funsightful]
I can't wait to play halflife three and watch rick and morty season three then.
HoZay said @ 10:28pm GMT on 21st Feb [Score:1 Good]
Ever the optimist.
sanepride said @ 10:13pm GMT on 21st Feb
This news only slightly alleviates my anxiety over Scott Pruitt taking the reins at EPA today.
lilmookieesquire said @ 10:18pm GMT on 21st Feb [Score:1 Funny]
You're like a political Clippy.
sanepride said @ 10:50pm GMT on 21st Feb [Score:1 Funsightful]
So steele made a new 'environment' category. I'm looking forward to prodigious posting of Secretary Pruitt's upcoming deregulation spree.
lilmookieesquire said[1] @ 11:57pm GMT on 21st Feb [Score:1 Funny]
sanepride said @ 12:12am GMT on 22nd Feb
Yeah, I remember Clippy.
And I wouldn't call it 'loosely related', it is, as my misguided friend midden would say, part of the cycle of things.
lilmookieesquire said @ 6:00am GMT on 22nd Feb


I kid, I kid.
midden said @ 10:41pm GMT on 21st Feb
Extinction events happen. I'm not saying they're fun to live through, but like winter, it's part of the cycle of things. They also open up the crowded field to new solutions to old problems.

My point is that it's not a question of the environment getting better or worse, just different. You know, like plagues and tornados.
sanepride said @ 10:47pm GMT on 21st Feb
"Of course the climate is changing. The climate is always changing!"
-oft repeated GOP talking point. Marco Rubio especially likes this one.

Helpful hint: read the first sentence of the Wikipedia entry on the Holocene Extinction.
spoiler alert: it's NOT part of the 'cycle of things'.
midden said[3] @ 11:17pm GMT on 21st Feb
Of course the climate is changing. And of course humans are a huge part of the cause. And humans are just as natural as anything else. And the Holocene Extinction is part of the cycle of things, like plagues that wipe out their host species then go extinct themselves. In all liklihood, the environment with all it's ever-changing biodiversity will continue on long after our species is Dust in the Wind.
Kansas - Dust in the Wind (Official Video)

(Only semi-ironically included.)

human population
sanepride said @ 11:51pm GMT on 21st Feb
No offense, but you're kind of taking the fatalistic 'it's god's will, so there's nothing we can do about it' argument.
No, the fact that we as a civilization (as opposed to merely another species) have at least the ability, if not the will to mitigate our destructive tendencies means that we are NOT 'as natural as anything else'. So by your thinking, that we're 'dust in the wind' anyway, we might as well just party down, shit and throw our trash anywhere we want, drive hummers, and not vote.
cakkafracle said[1] @ 12:48am GMT on 22nd Feb [Score:1 Underrated]
its not fatalistic God's Will
it's accepting Gaia as the earth mother who will take care of herself with or without us

I find it calming, not fatalistic

edit: a la http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0381825/
rylex said @ 12:59am GMT on 22nd Feb
i'm with you.

humans are so up our own asses, we actually think we could permanently affect the planet.

in reality, we will just permanently fuck it up for our use.
cakkafracle said @ 1:06am GMT on 22nd Feb
This concept saved me from chronic nightmares of nuclear holocaust back when the 1st gulf war was starting. Been with me ever since. Thanks, William Shatner!
rylex said @ 1:11am GMT on 22nd Feb
it's like Jeff Goldblum says in jurassic park.

"life will find a way".

and i also might add that the Earth survived for a few billion years without us, I think it can do just that again.
cakkafracle said @ 1:15am GMT on 22nd Feb
mmm, jeff goldblum
sanepride said @ 1:10am GMT on 22nd Feb
Sounds pretty fatalistic to me.
cakkafracle said @ 1:13am GMT on 22nd Feb
not fatal. Life!
sanepride said @ 1:30am GMT on 22nd Feb
Wikipedia definition -
Fatalism generally refers to any of the following ideas:

The view that we are powerless to do anything other than what we actually do.[1] Included in this is that man has no power to influence the future, or indeed, his own actions.[2] This belief is very similar to predeterminism.

An attitude of resignation in the face of some future event or events which are thought to be inevitable. Friedrich Nietzsche named this idea with "Turkish fatalism"[3] in his book The Wanderer and His Shadow.[4]

That acceptance is appropriate, rather than resistance against inevitability. This belief is very similar to defeatism.
cakkafracle said @ 2:24am GMT on 22nd Feb
yeah what i'm talking about is neither of those man. this isn't a binary thing
rylex said @ 1:15am GMT on 22nd Feb
I don't think its "fated". and i do believe/think we can fuck up the planet for us (nuclear winter anyone?). so, logically, i think we can also prevent our fucking it up.

but outside of this, i see a pattern in our planet's history that i realxe we might not be able to escape.
sanepride said @ 1:28am GMT on 22nd Feb
So if we can prevent it, why not try to prevent it?

Also, the original concept of nuclear winter as forwarded by Carl Sagan was the potential annihilation of all life on Earth.
cakkafracle said @ 2:25am GMT on 22nd Feb
the earth would be like back before there was life on earth!
Dienes said @ 3:26am GMT on 22nd Feb
Something is only bad if it creates lasting damage on a cosmic scale?

A completely preventable mass extinction is a permanent effect on the earth. Those species *might* be replaced with others in millions of years, but the ones that are lost are lost forever.

rylex said @ 6:28am GMT on 22nd Feb
species may be gone, but the earth will still exist.
even if it doesn't get repopulated by anything. that's the nature of existence
Dienes said @ 3:00pm GMT on 22nd Feb
I would love it if you would read Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming Into Existence by David Benatar and tell me your thoughts on it.
rylex said @ 8:56pm GMT on 22nd Feb
for sure! it sounds intriguing
midden said @ 2:09am GMT on 22nd Feb [Score:1 Underrated]
I don't mean it as fatalistic. If we are smart, we won't fuck up the planet for ourselves, but if we are not, it's probably not the end of the world.

When you are talking time scales of millions of years, as this article is, juxtaposing that with the idea of the environment "getting better" seems silly to me. Most species only last one million years or so. If they are really lucky, they might last ten. Even in Sagan's nuclear winter, I suspect there'd be the equivalent of the Cambrian Explosion a few million years after, as tiny critters repopulate the planet from deep sea and subterranean refuges to diversify into a whole new ecosystem.
cakkafracle said @ 2:29am GMT on 22nd Feb
see, if I tried to explain it it'd be way less coherent but this is how I think about it too.

and I don't feel fatal about it, i find it comforting that life will persist if its meant to.

hell, at least its a more hopeful position than any western religion... talk about fatalistic...
midden said @ 3:00am GMT on 22nd Feb [Score:1 Interesting]
God knows everything that ever happened or ever will happen (it's all part of his Plan), but you still have free will. No, really! God has known exactly what you are going to do since before the beginning of time, but it's still somehow your choice, and you will be horrifically punished for all eternity if God doesn't like those choices. If you happen to be headed for Hell, He created you knowing you were going to suffer eternally beyond all human imagining, and He did it anyway. So he must have actually wanted it that way. You never actually had a choice. The only reason you are going to suffer for eternity is because God is and asshole. Or the Church doesn't have a clue what it's talking about.

- My thoughts at age twelve before refusing to be Confirmed as a Catholic.
NuncEstBibendum said @ 9:31am GMT on 22nd Feb
George Carlin's take on the matter.

George Carlin - Saving the Planet


Plastic, assholes!

With all the gallows humor, I find it —as usual with his stuff— somehow refreshing.
Seeing a sketch like this, at first you could dismiss him as your usual nihilist-populist demagogue (in his final years he seemed to give in more and more to the bitter side). For me, nevertheless, there's always a deep humanistic kernel in his point of view and exposition. I think he can't help being sincerely revolutionary, even in his most eschatological, bleak moments.
Or maybe it's just his funny face and his beard that charms me, I don't know.
rylex said @ 1:01am GMT on 22nd Feb
global warming is actually a positive thing, assuming it prevents the next ice age we're headed towards.
sanepride said @ 1:09am GMT on 22nd Feb
Current events have messed up my sarcasm detector. I'm going to try to assume you're being sarcastic here.
rylex said @ 6:24am GMT on 22nd Feb
about 50/50 actually
XregnaR said @ 11:00pm GMT on 21st Feb
Plaguenado
NuncEstBibendum said @ 10:42am GMT on 22nd Feb

Post a comment
[note: if you are replying to a specific comment, then click the reply link on that comment instead]

You must be logged in to comment on posts.



Posts of Import
Karma
SE v2 Closed BETA
First Post
Subscriptions and Things

Karma Rankings
ScoobySnacks
HoZay
Paracetamol
lilmookieesquire
Ankylosaur